Three Books
July 23, 2008 – 2:51 pmSo far I’ve read three of my five books for October and I’ve loved them all, but for different reasons.
The first book I read was Jo Walton’s Half a Crown. This is the third (and final) book in her Small Change series, of which I am a tremendous fan. The series is incredibly dark and disturbing and every time I finish a book I say, “Poor Carmichael.” There’s is hope at the end of the third book–to say anything more would be a spoiler–but I still said, “Poor Carmichael.” Walton’s such a fantastic writer–she shifts between first and third person narration seamlessly and her three female narrators (Lucy, Viola, and Elvira) all have very different voices, even as they’re caught up in the same nightmare as Carmichael. It’s very satisfying to see all the pieces fit together at the end of each book, even as you’re cringing at the result–Walton never flinches. These are, I think, important books. They are a warning of what can happen if we give in to fear. I will probably never reread them. I don’t know if I can bear to.
The second book is The Hero of Ages by Brandon Sanderson, final book in the Mistborn Trilogy. I love Sanderson’s fantasy so very much–I am not a fan of Robert Jordan at all, but I feel pretty confident that he’s going to do a great job with the last book in the Wheel of Time series. He knows what’s what in epic fantasy. His world-building is intricate, logical, and consistent. He doesn’t have an overwhelming cast of characters, but he has enough so that there’s a good variety and they’re all distinct. The magical systems are really interesting and well thought out. And the very best part of all? He knows what all the tropes and cliches are in this particular sub-genre and he goes to town with turning them all upside down. It’s really fun to watch the plot unfold and you say to yourself, “Self, he can’t possibly be going there,” but then he does and he makes it work. So often these days epic fantasy seems to be a synonym for “big fat books with a million characters where it takes 300 pages for them to walk across town”, but I guarantee you that not a single page is wasted in the Mistborn Trilogy.
Finally, the last book I’ve read is Mercedes Lackey’s Foundation. It’s a Valdemar book about the founding of the Heraldic Collegium (first in a trilogy if I’m not mistaken–Lackey’s website is woefully out of date). And if this book were fan fiction, it would be of the flavor known as “crack fic”. Because it is compulsively readable and there’s a metric ass-ton of coincidences and guess what? I. Don’t. Care. I love the sentient telepathic white horses (er, Companions), I love the complete and total improbability of the plot line (our Hero is an abused child laborer at the start of the book and a trusted Herald Trainee by the end), and I love the complete and total wish fulfillment of it all. Everyone needs to read a fluffy candy coated book once in a while and there’s no shame whatsoever in indulging.
And not only do I need to write reviews of these books, I need to assign a rating to each one. I don’t get a lot of words to actually say what I think of the books–what I’ve said about each one above is more than I have space for in RT, because I need to do plot summary, too–so it’s complicated and a bit difficult. If I give them all the same rating–I did, after all, love them all–I’m somehow implying that they’re interchangeable when they’re not, but if I don’t then I feel like I’m making some sort of value judgment on the type of books they are, when they’re each a very fine example of their particular sub-category.
That’s probably the part that’s really frustrating–I don’t want to fall into the rut of liking every thing I read so much that I want to give them all 4.5 and 4 stars, but I also don’t want to downrank a book for a something that may technically be a flaw but that also may also be something that is expected in the type of book that it is. I’m not grading papers, I’m reviewing books for people who are pretty damn hardcore readers with a wide variety of tastes and preferences (this is where the tired phrase “fans of $foo will enjoy this book by $bar” comes into play).
And honestly, it’s really unusual for me to have a month where I absolutely love the majority of the books I’m reviewing. It’s more likely that I’ll feel sort of neutral towards most of them with one or two standouts. I’ve found that it’s a lot easier to write a review about a book I’m neutral towards than about one I absolutely love or hate.





